Sign in
TerminatedNo phase

Comparison of 3 Diagnostic Strategies of PE: Planar V/Q Scan, CTPA, and V/Q SPECT.

Key facts

Who runs it
University Hospital, Brest
Where
Canada, France, and Switzerland11 sites in 3 countriesChoose a country to see its sites
Trial code
Status
Terminated
People taking part
611 people enrolled
Started
10 Apr 2017
Ended
17 Dec 2024
Type of study
Interventional, 3 groupsOne group gets an existing treatment, for comparison.
Treatments tested
  • Planar V/Q-based strategy
  • CTPA-based strategy
  • V/Q SPECT-based strategy
Record updated
5 February 2025
Why it stopped
The enrollment process for patients is difficult.

Who can take part

Age
18 years and older
Sex
Women and men
Healthy volunteers
Cannot take part

The registry criteria, word for word

Show all 12 criteriaShow less

Who can take part

  • Outpatients with a clinically suspected PE (defined as an acute onset of new or worsening shortness of breath, chest pain, hemoptysis, presyncope, or syncope) without another obvious apparent cause
  • High pretest clinical probability of PE or a non-high pretest clinical probability but a positive D-Dimer test

Who cannot take part

  • Contraindication to contrast media (including renal insufficiency with a creatinine clearance lower than 30 ml/min)
  • Age less than 18 years
  • Patients with already confirmed PE
  • Patients with a clinically suspected high-risk pulmonary embolism (hypotension or shock)
  • Use of therapeutic doses of anticoagulants for more than 48 hours
  • Other indication for long-term use of anticoagulants
  • Life expectancy less than 3 months
  • Unable/unwilling to give informed consent
  • Unlikely to comply with study follow-up
  • Ongoing pregnancy or breastfeeding

This trial has no sites in United States.

It has sites in 3 countries. Choose a country to see its sites.

About the trial

What the trial wants to find out

Pulmonary embolism (PE) remains a diagnostic challenge. False negative testing exposes patient to the risk of potentially fatal recurrence. False positive testing exposes patients to potentially fatal unduly side effects of anticoagulants.

Read full original descriptionShow less

Current diagnostic strategies rely on the sequential use of pretest clinical probability, Ddimer test, and chest imaging. Two chest imaging modalities have been validated for PE diagnostic exclusion: Computed Tomography Pulmonary Angiography (CTPA) and planar V/Q scan. Main limitations of planar V/Q are the high proportion of non-conclusive results, therefore requiring additional testing and more complex diagnostic algorithms. Main limitations of CTPA are its higher radiation dose and contraindications (renal failure).

In a randomized trial that compared strategies based on CTPA and on planar V/Q scan, a 30% increase in the rate of PE diagnoses was found in the arm using CTPA, raising the hypothesis of over-diagnosing and over-treating PE when using CTPA.

V/Q Single Photon Emission CT (SPECT) is a new method of scintigraphic acquisition that has been reported to improve the diagnostic performances of the test, which could reduce the number of non-conclusive tests and allow simplified diagnostic algorithms.

The investigators hypothesize that a strategy based on V/Q SPECT could be an alternative to the two usual approaches responding rightly to the two mains issues and combining the advantages of CTPA (simplified diagnostic approach) and planar V/Q (no overdiagnosis, lower radiation exposure, no contraindication).

Although a recent survey showed that up to 70% of nuclear medicine centers perform SPECT rather than planar imaging for diagnosing PE, a diagnostic management outcome study, in which diagnostic decision would be made on the basis of a standardized algorithm based on the V/Q SPECT is lacking. Such a study needs to be conducted to ensure that the safety of diagnostic exclusion using a V/Q SPECT based strategy is non-inferior to that of previously validated strategies, and to verify that the use of V/Q SPECT does not lead to over-diagnosis.

The 3 groups in the trial

  • Planar V/Q-based strategyExisting treatment, for comparison

    Control arm

  • CTPA-based strategyExisting treatment, for comparison

    Control arm

  • V/Q SPECT-based strategyTreatment being tested

    Experimental arm

Data and sources

Registry record
Listed on ClinicalTrials.gov.
Official title
Comparison of 3 Diagnostic Strategies of Pulmonary Embolism : Planar Ventilation-perfusion Scintigraphy (Planar V/Q Scan), Computed Tomography Pulmonary Angiography (CTPA), and V/Q Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT)
Publications
Record updated
5 February 2025