Sign in
CompletedNo phase

Physical Restraints in Intensive Care Unit Patients

Key facts

Who runs it
University Hospital, Clermont-Ferrand
Where
France19 sites in 1 countryChoose a country to see its sites
Trial code
Status
Completed
People taking part
4,000 people enrolled
Started
18 May 2022
Ended
2 Feb 2026
Type of study
Interventional, 2 groupsOne group gets no study treatment, for comparison.
Treatments tested
  • ARBORea decision-making tool
Record updated
10 July 2026

Who can take part

Age
18 years and older
Sex
Women and men
Healthy volunteers
Cannot take part

The registry criteria, word for word

Show all 9 criteriaShow less

Who can take part

  • Patient, male or female, over 18 years of age, hospitalized in ICU for at least 48 hours
  • Consent to participate in the patient's study or authorization to carry out the research collected from the designated trustworthy person (failing this, a family member, or failing this, a close and stable relation with the person concerned) according to the modalities described in Title II of the book of the First Public Health Code. If no relative is present, the patient may be included on the advice of the investigator (article L. 1111-6). A consent form for continuation of the study and use of the data will then be signed by the patient if and when the patient is again conscious and lucid, or if the patient is unable to express consent, authorization to continue the research will be obtained from the designated trusted person
  • Patient covered by a social security system

Who cannot take part

  • Predictable and uninterrupted maintenance of deep sedation throughout the duration of the stay, due to the seriousness of the lesions, from the moment the patient is admitted to the intensive care unit
  • Lack of predictable remission of a severe coma present on admission to intensive care
  • Refusal to participate by the patient, or by the trusted person contacted by default
  • Patient with DNR (do not resuscitate) orders
  • Patient under legal protection
  • Patient already included in the protocol during another stay in resuscitation

This trial has no sites in United States.

It has sites in one country. Choose a country to see its sites.

About the trial

What the trial wants to find out

The use of physical restraints is common practice in Intensive Care Units (ICU). This medically prescribed procedure requires full attention of medical and paramedical teams for its implementation, monitoring and ending, as a major restriction of patients\' individual freedom. French highest authority for health has defined, for geriatrics and psychiatric units, ten criteria of good practice for physical restraints' use. Routine practice reports critically ill patients' safety as main reason of use. This decision, often left to the sole discretion of nurses, varies according to their own representation of this risk, and depends on several factors: seniority in ICU, nurse to patient ratio and personal workload.

Read full original descriptionShow less

In order to reduce practices subjectivity and heterogeneity, we have developed a decision-making tool for physical restraints implementation. This tool is based on objective scales used on a daily basis concerning neurological status (Richmond Agitation-Sedation Scale (RASS) and Confusion Assessment Method for the ICU (CAM-ICU)). Disorientation or delirium can lead to severe incidents by promoting accidental removing of important devices such as arterial of venous line, drains among others. However, physical restraints are recognized as a major cause of delirium and agitation.

Critically ill patients require rigorous evaluation of organ dysfunctions necessitating adequate invasive equipments, with associated risks of unexpected removal or alteration. Such events could urge caregivers to use physical restraints. Based on recent literature, about a third of ICU patients are restrained, and accidental deconditioning is mainly observed within these particular patients.

In addition, three categories of patients have been defined according to the invasive nature of their equipment and therefore according to the risk associated with an unexpected withdrawal. Finally, presence of patient\'s family and their adherence to its surveillance were also implemented into the tool. Main study objective is to jointly investigate effectiveness and tolerance of a decision-making tool guiding physical restraints use in ICU patients.

The 2 groups in the trial

  • ARBORea decision-making toolTreatment being tested

    After a period of presentation and training on the dedicated decision-making tool (face-to-face, video and paper supports), nurses will be asked to use ARBORéa decision tree. This will be in the form of an electronic file and will give a suggestion of whether or not to use physical restraints. This is based on an algorithm based on specific and mandatory elements (neurological state : RASS (Richmond assessment sedation scale) and CAM-ICU (confusion assessment method-ICU) scores, modification of sedation dosage, pain assessment and the presence of analgesics, equipment levels, presence and adhesion of the family) that will be completed online. ARBORea's suggestion will be collected as well as final caregiver's decision in order to evaluate relevance of the tool. Observations will also be made at least every 8 hours. This period will also be of random duration (stepped wedge)

  • Subjective physical restraints useNo study treatment, for comparison

    After study presentation and required data collection description, nurses will complete elements related to ARBORea's tool variables, and inform their actual practices of physical restraints use, at least every 8 hours. ARBORea data concern patient's neurological state (RASS and CAM-ICU scores) and changes in sedation doses. The conditioning will then be filled in to stratify the risk incurred. Pain management will be notified. Finally, the presence and involvement of the families will be collected. Other data, relating to working conditions of the nurses will be collected: nurse to patient ratio, special and time consuming events (new patient admission, in ICU emergencies, need to conduct a patient to CT-scan facility or operative room, change of patient's equipment). Nurse seniority in ICU will be specified. Incidents that have occurred (fall, self-injury, removal of a level C2 equipment). The random duration of this control period will be determined by stepped wedge sequencing.

Data and sources

Registry record
Listed on ClinicalTrials.gov.
Official title
Impact of a Decision-making Tool to Guide the Use of Physical Restraints in Intensive Care Unit Patients. A Multicentre Randomized Stepped-wedge Trial.
Publications
Record updated
10 July 2026