Sign in
CompletedNo phase

Hand vs. Foot Chest Compressions in Simulation

Key facts

Who runs it
Hospital Clinic of Barcelona
Where
Spain1 site in 1 countryChoose a country to see its sites
Trial code
Status
Completed
People taking part
128 people enrolled
Started
6 Jun 2025
Ended
17 Jun 2025
Type of study
Interventional, 2 groupsOne group gets an existing treatment, for comparison.
Treatments tested
  • Performing chest compressions on a mannequin using the foot
  • Performance of standard chest compressions with the upper limbs.
Record updated
20 July 2025

Who can take part

Age
18 years and older
Sex
Women and men
Healthy volunteers
Can take part

The registry criteria, word for word

Show all 6 criteriaShow less

Who can take part

  • Age 18 years or older
  • Signed informed consent
  • First-year postgraduate trainees in health-related fields such as medicine or nursing
  • Enrolled in a Basic Life Support and Automated External Defibrillation (BLS+AED) course from the Consell Català de Resuscitació - European Resuscitation Council

Who cannot take part

  • Contraindications for physical exercise (e.g., arthritis, heart disease, advanced lung disease, severe physical disability, morbid obesity, chronic fatigue, pregnancy)
  • Physical limitations preventing chest compressions with hands or feet

Where is this trial?

It has sites in one country. Choose a country to see its sites.

About the trial

What the trial wants to find out

Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) is essential in the management of cardiorespiratory arrest (CA) to improve survival rates. High-quality chest compressions are the primary intervention to maintain circulation and oxygenation of vital organs during cardiac arrest, making them a key determinant in CPR effectiveness.

Read full original descriptionShow less

Guidelines emphasize that the quality of chest compressions is a critical factor in the effectiveness of basic life support (BLS). To ensure efficacy, a compression rate of 100 to 120 per minute is recommended, with a depth of at least 5 cm but not exceeding 6 cm, proper arm and hand alignment, full chest recoil after each compression, minimal interruptions during CPR, and rescuer rotation every 2 minutes to prevent performance decline due to fatigue.

As we can see, these guidelines refer to performing compressions using the upper limbs. However, it is essential to acknowledge that some individuals have physical limitations that may impair their ability to apply effective force with their upper limbs (e.g., amputations, fractures, neuromuscular dysfunctions). This presents important challenges regarding accessibility and inclusive CPR training. In addition, the use of the lower extremities has been proposed as an alternative to potentially reduce rescuer fatigue, although evidence regarding its effectiveness and impact on physiological fatigue is still limited.

There are studies comparing chest compressions performed with the hands (Hands Method, HMM) and with the feet (Foot Method, FMM); however, these studies have certain limitations and a limited number of participants. Although the quality of CPR was lower when using the feet technique, the results were positive.

However, to date, no specific guidelines have been established on how to perform CPR using the feet (Foot CPR), and it remains unclear whether the position of the feet on the chest or whether compressions are performed with or without shoes are variables that influence compression quality.

Furthermore, during CPR, it is recommended to rotate rescuers every 2 minutes when two or more rescuers are available due to fatigue associated with the procedure. Current evidence suggests that CPR is most effectively performed in the kneeling position, rather than standing or using a stool, due to the lower levels of fatigue in this position.

Traditionally, exercise-induced fatigue is assessed using subjective perception of exertion (RPE), performance monitoring (e.g., power or speed), or biochemical markers (e.g., blood lactate). More recently, heart rate variability (HRV) has been proposed as a valuable tool for assessing the autonomic nervous system response to exercise stress and quantifying physiological fatigue.

After exercise, especially if it is intense or prolonged, the body experiences significant physiological stress. This stress affects multiple systems, including the cardiovascular and autonomic nervous systems. Post-exercise fatigue is a complex sensation involving muscular, metabolic, and neuronal factors. Therefore, HRV becomes a valuable biomarker.

Numerous studies have shown a correlation between decreased HRV and the subjective perception of fatigue after exercise. People with lower heart rate variability (HRV) after exercise tend to report higher levels of fatigue. HRV analysis provides an objective and physiological measure of the stress the body experiences after short-duration, high-intensity exercise, such as that performed during resuscitation.

Therefore, measuring HRV after 2 minutes of chest compressions can indicate the degree of exercise-induced physiological fatigue, which could vary depending on the technique used (Hands-on CPR [H-CPR] vs. Feet-on CPR [F-CPR]).

Efforts to improve outcomes should focus on optimizing the chain of survival through training in Basic Life Support and Automated External Defibrillation (BLS + AED). Offering these courses to the general population presents significant challenges in terms of accessibility and implementation of comprehensive and inclusive training.

The objective of our randomized simulation study using mannequins, with a population of Basic Life Support students, was to compare the quality of chest compressions and the fatigue produced by this technique, in compressions performed with the hands and with the foot.

The 2 groups in the trial

  • HM - Hand MethodExisting treatment, for comparison

    Treatment: Performance of standard chest compressions with the upper limbs.

  • FM - Foot MethodTreatment being tested

    Treatment: Performing chest compressions on a mannequin using the foot

Data and sources

Registry record
Listed on ClinicalTrials.gov.How to verify a trial in the registry
Official title
Comparative Study of Hand vs. Foot Chest Compressions in a Simulated Environment: Assessment of Compression Effectiveness and Rescuer Fatigue
Record updated
20 July 2025